No relaxation of civil aviation safety norms even for project by public authority: Bombay HC


PTI, Jan 15, 2024, 1:53 PM IST

Civil aviation safety norms cannot be relaxed even for a project by a public authority, the Bombay High Court held while dismissing the MHADA’s petition against an order passed by the Union Ministry denying it permission to construct a 40-storey building near the airport here.

A division bench of Justices Gautam Patel and Kamal Khata on January 10 dismissed the petition filed by the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA) against a decision taken by the appellate authority of the Ministry of Civil Aviation in December 2021 setting a height restriction for a residential building proposed near the Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj International Airport.

The court, in its order, said the MHADA certainly cannot claim a legal, let alone constitutional, right to a taller building. ”It cannot contend that civil aviation safety standards should not apply to it. It cannot contend that merely because this is an MHADA project, it exceeding a mandated height poses no danger to civil aviation,” the court said.

The court further said it was reluctant to accept the proposition, ”one that paints quite a startling picture, of aircraft at the CSMIA weaving and swooping around an oversized MHADA tower as they take off or land”. As per the plea, the MHADA has proposed a building of a height of 115.54 meters (nearly 40 floors) for middle or low-income housing of 560 tenements. While the maximum permissible height was 58.48 meters, the MHADA filed an appeal before the appellate authority, which then granted permission for 96.68 meters. The bench, in its order, noted that there was no question of arbitrariness (in the order), and in fact, the appellate authority order was favourable to the MHADA. ”The MHADA is not being selectively targeted for the height restriction. If anything, it is the other way around,” the court said. It further stated that if any relaxation is given to the MHADA then the same relaxation would have to be given to every other developer, including a private party. ”No relaxation of civil aviation safety norms can be granted only because the project proponent is a public authority. Aviation safety has nothing to do with the identity of the developer,” the court held. While dismissing the plea, the bench said such a petition should never have been filed, especially by a responsible public authority. ”Why the MHADA needs a building of 40 floors is unexplained. But this proposed building falls within the four-kilometre radius of the airport run by the Mumbai International Airport Ltd (MIAL),” the court said. The bench added that the Airport Authority of India has specified height restrictions that follow internationally mandated aviation safety standards and norms. ”There are no exemptions just because these are middle-income group housing schemes or because the applicant is MHADA,” the court said. The bench noted that the December 2021 order was passed by the Appellate Authority of the Ministry of Civil Aviation which presumably has at ”the forefront of its mind and decision-making processes concerns of civil aviation as paramount”.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Kinnigoli: Truck carrying red stone collides with Auto-Rickshaw; driver injured

UP govt to install 150,000 toilets for Maha Kumbh, set up paying guest facilities

Kavoor Police arrest two notorious cattle thieves

Udupi: Unidentified body found near Bailkere’s Vidhyodaya School

Sexual harassment case cannot be closed on basis of compromise between parties: SC

MLC Ivan D’Souza defends CM Siddaramaiah’s Lokayukta appearance, criticizes BJP’s ‘Drama’ claims

Ranji Trophy: Shreyas Iyer’s majestic 233 puts Mumbai in complete command against Odisha

Related Articles More

Felling of trees: What is being done to restore Delhi Ridge? SC asks DDA

UP govt to install 150,000 toilets for Maha Kumbh, set up paying guest facilities

Sexual harassment case cannot be closed on basis of compromise between parties: SC

BJP slams Rahul Gandhi over his recent opinion piece, calls it ‘laughable’

I’m not anti-business, I’m anti-monopoly: Rahul

MUST WATCH

Gho Pooja in Deepavali Festival

Melukote Deepavali

Ganapathi Co-operative Society Ltd

Udayavani Chinnara Banna 2024

Annapoorna Aahar | Food Places In Mysore


Latest Additions

Felling of trees: What is being done to restore Delhi Ridge? SC asks DDA

Kinnigoli: Truck carrying red stone collides with Auto-Rickshaw; driver injured

UP govt to install 150,000 toilets for Maha Kumbh, set up paying guest facilities

Kavoor Police arrest two notorious cattle thieves

Udupi: Unidentified body found near Bailkere’s Vidhyodaya School

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.