Governor’s action shall not be arbitrary: Supreme Court


Team Udayavani, May 19, 2018, 10:36 AM IST

New Delhi/Bengaluru: The Supreme Court on Thursday ordered the appointment of a pro-term Speaker to conduct a floor test to decide the majority in the Karnataka Assembly. The responsibility of appointing the Speaker lies with the Governor of the State. Article 180 (1) of the Constitution gives the Governor the power to appoint a pro-tem Speaker.

But the issue is that the Article does not lay down the extent to which this power can be exercised. The Congress party’s challenge in the Supreme Court that the appointment of V.P. Bopaiah by Karnataka Governor Vajubhai Vala is an “arbitrary” use of his discretion. The BJP defended the Governor’s appointment by quoting Article 163 (2) of the Constitution, which says that “the validity of anything done by the Governor shall not be called in question on the ground that he ought or ought not to have acted in his discretion.”

In the Nabam Rebia judgement of 2016 given by a Bench of the Supreme Court led by then Chief Justice J.S. Khehar observed that the Article does not give Governors a “general discretionary power”. This time around, the Constitution Bench has laid down that the area of discretion of the Governor is limited and in this limited area, the choice of action should not be arbitrary or fanciful. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar described in one of his speeches that a Governor should use his discretion not as “representative of a party” but as “the representative of the people as a whole of the State”.

This also raises a question as to whether or not the discretion of the Governor can be judicially reviewed by the Supreme Court. A Constitution Bench judgement in 2006 in the Rameshwar Prasad case observed that the “immunity granted to the Governor under Article 361 (1) does not affect the power of the Court to judicially scrutinise the attack….”

But, given that the powers of the pro-tem Speaker are wide and almost equivalent to that of the elected Speaker, then any apprehensions about his appointment will have to be dispelled since the proceedings of the Legislature chaired by the Speaker pro-tem are as much protected under the Constitution as those chaired by the elected Speaker.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

SC notice to Karnataka, DK Shivakumar on CBI plea against withdrawal of consent by state govt

Will remain active in politics till my last breath: JD(S) patriarch & ex-PM Deve Gowda

BJP calls Congress govt ‘laughing stock’ as ‘samosa politics’ heats up in Himachal

Chikkaballapur: Yoga teacher feigns death by holding her breath, escapes murder bid

World Bunts Summit to be held in Mumbai on December 7

SC dismisses PIL seeking CBI probe into Tirupati laddus row

Salman Khan gets another threat; message sent to Mumbai traffic police helpline

Related Articles More

SC notice to Karnataka, DK Shivakumar on CBI plea against withdrawal of consent by state govt

Will remain active in politics till my last breath: JD(S) patriarch & ex-PM Deve Gowda

New kind of ”Jihad” in Karnataka through Waqf Board, alleges Union Minister Pralhad Joshi

Chikkaballapur: Yoga teacher feigns death by holding her breath, escapes murder bid

Leopard spotted near M’luru airport, Forest Dept begins search operation

MUST WATCH

Gho Pooja in Deepavali Festival

Melukote Deepavali

Ganapathi Co-operative Society Ltd

Udayavani Chinnara Banna 2024

Annapoorna Aahar | Food Places In Mysore


Latest Additions

Sensex, Nifty fall for 2nd day on FII selling; RIL, ICICI Bank major drag

Akhilesh Yadav attacks BJP on demonetisation anniversary

SC notice to Karnataka, DK Shivakumar on CBI plea against withdrawal of consent by state govt

DeMo paved way for monopolies by devastating MSMEs, informal sector: Rahul on note ban anniversary

Will remain active in politics till my last breath: JD(S) patriarch & ex-PM Deve Gowda

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.