Article 370 was meant to be ‘temporary’ provision in Constitution: Amit Shah


PTI, May 15, 2023, 4:18 PM IST

The now-scrapped Article 370, which gave special status to Jammu and Kashmir, was meant to be a ”temporary” provision since the beginning and the framers of the Constitution had put it there ”intelligently”, Union Home Minister Amit Shah said on Monday.

Inaugurating a training programme on legislative drafting, Shah also said that if a legislation is drafted well, there is ”no need for any court to give any explanation to any law”.

If the drafting is simple and clear, it will also be easier to educate people about the law with minimal chances of errors by the executive, he said and added that if ”grey areas” are left in the drafting, they will lead to ”encroachment” in interpretation. Shah said if the drafting is complete and lucid, its interpretation will also be clear.

Referring to Article 370, which the BJP government at the Centre repealed in 2019, the home minister said the whole country wanted that the provision of the Constitution should not be in existence.

He also highlighted that when the Article was framed, it was mentioned in the index as ”Temporary Provision of Article 370”. Even debates on the Article were missing from the records of constituent assembly debates, Shah said and added that they were not printed.

Shah said it could well be imagined that whoever had drafted it and those who were part of the constituent assembly, how intelligently they put it and how after lots of thought the ”temporary” word was inserted.

”An article of the Constitution cannot be temporary, it can be amended. If you read it even today — the old Constitution, it is clearly written as Temporary Provision of Article 370,” he said.

”Article 370 is no longer in existence. It has been repealed now. But please read it. It was mentioned in the index as ‘Temporary Provision of Article 370’. If this ‘temporary’ word was not written, what would have happened. Tell me, can a provision of the Constitution be ‘temporary’,” he asked.

The Article was scrapped on August 5, 2019, a few months after Shah took charge as the country’s home minister, and the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir was bifurcated into union territories of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh.

The home minister said that a ”legislation should reflect the political will of the Cabinet or Parliament”. ”A law becomes undisputed if it is simple and clear. It (a law) should be framed in a way that the court does not need to make any explanation. When there is no need for any court to give any explanation to any law, that is a medal for you. Our aim has to be to draft a law as simple and clear as possible,” Shah said.

When a law is made with ambiguities, it creates problems, the minister said and added that ”if a law is made simple and clear, there is no need for the judiciary to intervene as grey areas leave scope for overstepping”.

He said drafting of ”the spirit of the legislature” is very significant work as simple translation is not sufficient and there has to be a proper explanation for it.

The home minister said the drafting skill of those who work in the legislative wing of Parliament and of state legislatures should be improved because the world is changing very rapidly.

Appreciating Parliament authorities for holding the training session, he said capacity building is very necessary and it has to be a continuous process. ”We have to take proper action in this changing world and the laws have to be made according to today’s requirements. If we don’t have that kind of openness, we will be irrelevant,” Shah said.

The home minister also said the BJP government under Narendra Modi has made lots of changes in laws. ”We have scrapped nearly 2,000 irrelevant laws. Also, we have not hesitated to frame new laws,” Shah said.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Siddaramaiah will resign as CM before Belagavi assembly session, claims BJP’s Vijayendra

Champions Trophy: ICC puts PCB’s ‘PoK’ tour on hold after BCCI’s strong objection

Suriya-starrer ‘Kanguva’ mints Rs 58.62 crore in worldwide gross on day one

Mangaluru: Car catches fire near Kadri Police Station

J-K: 2 teenage boys driving SUV die in road accident; sparks calls to curb underage driving

Forest department creating hurdles in development of Gadchiroli district: Gadkari

700 kg drugs seized, 8 Iranians caught in anti-narcotics operation along Gujarat coast

Related Articles More

Maharashtra: Jewellers face challenges in business as wedding season clashes with poll season

Maharashtra Elections | CM Shinde using Marathi TV serials for campaigning, Congress alleges

Misuse of social media platforms by terrorists to be borne in mind by courts while sentencing: HC

Forest department creating hurdles in development of Gadchiroli district: Gadkari

Ensure level playing field in campaigning: Congress to EC after Rahul’s chopper delay

MUST WATCH

| ₹50 LAKH SEIZED FROM TIRE |

New Technology In Kambala

Lakshdeepotsava 2024 Shree Krishna Mutt

Punganur Cow

Rangoli design


Latest Additions

Siddaramaiah will resign as CM before Belagavi assembly session, claims BJP’s Vijayendra

Mangaluru: 3 key suspects in cyber fraud cases arrested

Yakshadhruva Patla Foundation women’s wing launched in Udupi

Champions Trophy: ICC puts PCB’s ‘PoK’ tour on hold after BCCI’s strong objection

Maharashtra: Jewellers face challenges in business as wedding season clashes with poll season

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.