SC judges should avoid harsh words: Ravi Shankar Prasad


PTI, Jul 9, 2019, 9:06 AM IST

New Delhi: Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad said in Rajya Sabha Monday that the Supreme Court judges should avoid “harsh words” and referred to the observations like “constitutional fraud” in the minority judgement in the landmark Aadhaar verdict.

Replying to a debate on a bill to amend law to allow voluntary use of Aadhaar as ID proof for opening bank accounts and obtaining mobile phone connections, Prasad said the government respects apex court judges and they too should reciprocate.

“It is a remarkable minority judgment… with all humility I want to say this in the House today. We respect Supreme Court judges but use of words such as constitutional fraud should not happen,” Prasad, who is also the minister for Information and Technology, said.

He did not name the judge but his comments clearly seemed in response to Congress leader Jairam Ramesh citing a 500-page dissenting judgement by Justice D Y Chandrachud on the passage of the Aadhaar Bill as a money bill in Parliament under the BJP-led government’s first term.

Ramesh had quoted the judge to say that the Act “constitutes a fraud on the Constitution.”

“Passing of a Bill as a Money Bill, when it does not qualify for it, damages balance of bicameralism which is part of the basic structure of the Constitution,” Ramesh quoted the judge as saying.

The Supreme Court by a majority judgement had upheld passing of the Aadhaar Bill as Money Bill.

Money Bills can be introduced only in Lok Sabha and must be returned by Rajya Sabha to Lok Sabha within 14 days or the bill is deemed to have been passed by both houses in the form passed by the Lok Sabha.

The ruling NDA lacks majority in Rajay Sabha.

Also Rajya Sabha can only recommend amendments. The Lok Sabha Speaker certifies the bill as a money bill before sending it to the upper house.

“I can say with full sense of responsibility that harsh words, like constitutional fraud, must be avoided even by a lone judge, who is the dissenting judge,” Prasad said in Rajya Sabha said without naming anyone.

He said the learned judge had stated that the fathers of Indian Constitution had opined that majority governments are dictatorships.

“Where did this come from,” he wondered, adding he confronted the judge at the Law Day function at national capital’s Vigyan Bhawan. “It is there in the judgement. And, I have to say it openly that these kinds of sweeping comments, at best, be avoided.”

Defending the amendments that were necessitated by the Supreme Court ruling that held it illegal to make Aadhaar an ID proof in absence of a supporting law, he said the 12-digit biometric does not pose any threat to privacy.
He went on to cite comments by Microsoft founder Bill Gates and other foreign organisations to support his view.

The Amendments, which were passed by Rajya Sabha by voice votes, were to provide legitimacy to what the Surpeme Court had said.

Prasad said any citizen cannot be denied government support for lack of Aadhaar.

“No poor will ever be deprived of his ration. All we have said is that please apply for Aadhaar but supply of foodgrains based on alternative proofs cannot be stopped, he said.

This despite Aadhaar being mandatory for release of any funds from the Consolidated Fund of India, he said.

Lok Sabha had passed the amendments last week and with Rajya Sabha’s approval, the parliamentary process for making changes in the law are complete.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Explainer: HMPV not a new pathogen, cases have been reported worldwide

SpaDeX docking postponed to January 9: ISRO

What to know about the siege outside South Korea’s presidential compound

Shooting attack on bus carrying Israelis in occupied West Bank kills 3

Assembly row: TN Guv leaving House without reading address ‘childish,’ says CM Stalin

Study finds graffiti marks from TN archaeological sites similar to Indus Valley Civilisation signs

HMPV cases: Karnataka Health Minister says no reason to panic

Related Articles More

Explainer: HMPV not a new pathogen, cases have been reported worldwide

Three killed after bus falls into gorge in Kerala’s Idukki

SpaDeX docking postponed to January 9: ISRO

Infant in Ahmedabad hospital tests positive for HMPV; stable

Assembly row: TN Guv leaving House without reading address ‘childish,’ says CM Stalin

MUST WATCH

Tulunadu Daivaradane

Feeding Birds with Creative Paddy Art!

Areca Nut

HOTEL SRI DURGA BHAVANA

Harish Poonja


Latest Additions

8-year-old girl collapses and dies in classroom

Injured Jasprit Bumrah likely to miss majority of home white-ball series against England

Educational Program for Young Diabetics organised at Kasturba Hospital, Manipal

Explainer: HMPV not a new pathogen, cases have been reported worldwide

Three killed after bus falls into gorge in Kerala’s Idukki

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.