Too much tax, high interest rates biggest hurdles for growth of auto industry: Force Motors

PTI, Sep 13, 2020, 11:46 AM IST

New Delhi: Excessive tax and high-interest rates are the two biggest impediments in the growth and profitability of the automotive industry in the country, according to Force Motors.

The Pune-based company, which makes commercial vehicles under the Traveller brand and utility vehicle Trax, besides a range of tractors, said the situation calls for a very detailed and thorough reform.

The Indian automotive industry, having grown and matured, remains burdened with two major handicaps which are serious constraints to the growth of the market as well as encouraging investments and ensure the profitability of the industry, the automaker said in its Annual Report for 2019-20.

The issues particularly affect domestic companies, other than multinational firms operating in the country, the company noted.

“The first unfortunate factor is the very high-interest cost in comparison to the global industry which makes investments very burdensome particularly in times where the technology scenario is rapidly changing and new investments in technologies, products, plants and business practices have to be aggressively made,” Force Motors said.

The difference in interest rates when compared to developed countries is in the range of 6-8 per cent which grossly impacts the competitiveness of the industry, it added.

The second adverse factor is very high GST level and also very high road taxes imposed on automobiles in the country with the total incidence of taxation being 50 per cent in case of certain segments, the automaker said.

The auto manufacturers earn around Rs 10 lakh on each crore in its turnover and out of that it has to pay interest, tax, and depreciation, etc, it noted.

Whereas the government collects taxes on the same vehicle which is sold by the industry at Rs 10 lakh to the aggregate value of taxes at nearly Rs 5 lakh thus between central and state governments, up to 50 per cent of the ex-factory value is collected in taxes, Force Motors said.

“This situation calls for a very detailed and thorough reform. These reforms need to be both economic and regulatory reforms (Motor Vehicles Act, state government permits, license regime, etc),” it said.

Going forward in the post-COVID-19 era when the auto industry is gasping for breath, on account of the huge compression in the first half of the current year and the effects of which will be felt for several years, such fundamental reform is crucial, it added.

The automaker said it focuses on light commercial and medium commercial vehicles, including their electric versions. All of these market segments are heavily regulated and thereby suppressed, it added.

“The disparate and very much arbitrary system of allowing and restricting permits, licenses, etc to operate passenger vehicles for hire, to fix the fee and geographies of operation is most obnoxious and retrograde,” the company said.

It throttles competition, goes against the interest of the consumer, breeds open and rampant corruption, it added.

Besides causing capacity restriction, overloading, and general inconvenience to the travelling public, the system especially hurts the economically weak segments which use public transport, it noted. This needs to be made an open field in the interest of the consumer, the automaker said.

The COVID-19 situation offers the country an unprecedented opportunity to revamp modernize, energize and liberate its economy, Force Motors noted.

“The huge tangle of red tape, the plethora of complex and confusing laws – creating delays, losses, litigation and breeding opportunity for corruption and malpractices need, in a swift and decisive manner to be modified, simplified and like other advanced and industrialized countries made supportive and helpful to productive industrial activity,” it added.

On the government’s push towards electric mobility, the company said, “While on one hand, it is welcome on the other hand it demands major industry structure change not just terms of the technology but in the overall business environment and regulatory framework.”

Force Motors recently announced to undertake an enterprise-wide cost optimization in all areas of its vehicle business in the wake of a slowdown in the auto sector, the impact of the BS-VI transition, and the coronavirus pandemic.

It sold 25,229 units last fiscal as compared with 27,603 units in 2018-19.

The company’s sales turnover stood at Rs 3,053.08 crore last fiscal as against Rs 3,620.01 crore in 2018-19.

In the quarter ended June 30, the company had posted a consolidated net loss of Rs 64.99 crore against a consolidated net profit of Rs 26.17 crore in the year-ago quarter.

The company’s revenue from operations also came down to Rs 185.4 crore in the first quarter of this fiscal from Rs 802.48 crore in the same period last year.